The stats on the CO lines.

IMO, you have proven that the problem isn't with your Magix by using L#1 as a test line on the other line ports of the Magix.
Now you must determine what the difference is between L#1 compaired to 2,3,4,and 5 on the CO side.

I'll sent you over a test sheet that we use.

Avaya SMB Authorized Business Partner. ACIS/APSS
ESI Certified Reseller/Installer
www.regal-comm.com