Here are the readings that I took from the 2 lines:

Line1 Line2
On-Hook DCV 51.2 42.7
Off-Hook DCV 6.11 5.97
On-Hook ACV .4 .4
AC Ring Voltage 106 97.9

First, are these the correct measurements that I needed to take? Also, according to the Telephone Line Diagnostic Table from Mike Sandman, these readings are within spec.