atcomsystems.ca/forum
Posted By: Mike Andruschak Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/22/08 08:16 AM
I get to install a new Call Center, I'm working on the layout of equipment racks and cabinets. I know that out in the open office there is a 36" aisle requirement. Is there any requirement for the clearance between the backside of my rack mounted equipment and the walls? 30" would be enough for me to work comfortably and would give me a four foot wide aisle up the middle between the frontsides of the equipment racks and cabinets.
Posted By: Silversam Re: Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/22/08 09:29 AM
Mike -

A long time back (25 years) I installed a CO at a hospital here in NYC. I had my crew chalk out the floor before starting to install the bays. Good thing. It turned out the hospital sent the wrong scale on the floor plan to GTE's engineering dept.

Anyway, I had to really shrink the aisles to make everything fit. At the time I went to OSHA and got their minimum requirements for pathways and walkways.

I THINK (and my memory could be wrong, and/or the requiremnents could have changed) that the minimum was 30" then for equipment room walkways. The interbay spacing might have been as little as 27".

My advice is, (lacking guidance from the customer) get the minimums from OSHA and then build up from there.

Sam
Posted By: MNCommunications Re: Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/22/08 12:05 PM
I only suggest getting as much as you can somebody will always come in behind you and mount something in your way after you are done and gone, you will find out when you go back for a service call of some kind.
Posted By: jwooten Re: Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/22/08 02:52 PM
This is a very good question. Because you are not in a "public access" area and you may be in a room with power panels, one standard may offer no guidance while another does. As a rule, I always start my rack placement at 3ft. When double-sided shelves are installed clearance can get down to less than 2ft. Know the product you're installing and how much real estate it will take.
Posted By: nfcphoneman Re: Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/22/08 03:14 PM
I've always made the assumption that you should have at least a 3' clearance between the front of the rack and the back wall. I believe the NEC requires a 36" clearance be maintained for anyone working on an electrical connection, even if it is low voltage. But, I could be wrong...
Posted By: jeffmoss26 Re: Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/22/08 03:49 PM
Electrical panels you are supposed to have three feet clear around. Most of our rooms have yellow tape in front of the breaker panels, and signs that say 'Do Not Block Panel', yet that seems to be the place they stack everything.
Posted By: EV607797 Re: Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/22/08 04:33 PM
I would like to think that this type of installation does technically fall under the general guidelines of the NEC, meaning that a full 36" of front-facing work space must be provided from either side. It's a bit of a gray area though since many AHJ's (Authorities Having Jurisdiction), or inspectors are wishy-washy in how they apply the code requirements.

The NEC also has stipulations regarding pipes, structures, etc. that are mounted above panels, disconnects, transformers or other fixed equipment. It's up to the AHJ to decide if low-voltage equipment in cabinets falls into this category. My guess would be "no" since racks are considered to be portable equipment, as in not a permanent part of the building's electrical system. This would be especially true if all electrical components within the rack are cord and plug connected.

With that being said, a quick call to the electrical inspector's office sounds to be in order. I think that you'll get more of a suggestion from them rather than any level of enforcement. I can't imagine having anything less than 36" of working space anyway, especially if the cabinets involve sliding shelves.

Welcome to the gray area of the NEC. For every requirement, there are usually at least two exceptions elsewhere within the book. I wish I could offer a more definitive answer, but there really isn't one with regard to the NEC. A cabinet or rack is about the equivalent to a refrigerator in the view of the code.

Just remember, nearly every jurisdiction maintains quite a few requirements above and beyond NEC requirements. Local codes always supersede the NEC, so that's why you need to ask this question of the AHJ or code compliance department in your local city, town or county.
Posted By: Silversam Re: Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/22/08 05:44 PM
My experience was that Telecom Equipment did NOT fall under the NEC. When I worked for GTE, as a utility they did not have to abide by the NEC. Bell was notorious for that - including 120/240 electrical work which they claimed exemption from (GTE claimed exemption under the DC portion, not the AC, but as a rule their regulations were MUCH stricter than the NECs, so it didn't matter.)

Sam
Posted By: 5Etek-mike Re: Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/22/08 05:54 PM
I agree as well that it's best to consult directly with the property's local inspectors, just to be on the safe side. :thumb:

Just wanted to add that this is a great topic, Mike. I saw your post this morning, and have been digging thru the NEC, FCC Part 68, and others just to see what I could find as well. The only true reference that I could locate in writing (other than in many College and University locally enforced codes) was in ANSI/TIA/EIA-942 [Telecommunications Infrastructure Standard for Data Centers]

Here's the copy and pasted reference:

Hot and Cold Aisles

Cabinets and racks shall be arranged in an alternating pattern, with fronts
of cabinets/racks facing each other in a row to create “hot” and “cold” aisles.
Cold aisles are in front of racks and cabinets. If there is an access floor, power
distribution cables should be installed here under the access floor on the slab.
Hot aisles are behind racks and cabinets. If there is an access floor, cable trays
for telecommunications cabling should be located under the access floor in the
hot aisles. A minimum of 1 m (3 ft) of front clearance shall be provided for installation
of equipment. A front clearance of 1.2 m (4 ft) is preferable to accommodate
deeper equipment. A minimum of 0.6 m (2 ft) of rear clearance shall
be provided for service access at the rear of racks and cabinets.
A rear clearance of 1 m (3 ft) is preferable. Some equipment
may require service clearances of greater than 1 m (3 ft).

Unfortunately, I'm unable to post the link here, due to it containing parentheses; so I've sent the link to your email.

It's always best to check and confirm with the local inspectors.

Big Congrats on the install! :thumb:
Posted By: KCDataDude124 Re: Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/23/08 12:57 PM
Congrats on the install.

One note of caution is some of the newer IBM & Sun equipment is coming in at 39"+ of depth. Some equipment cabinets are 42" deep and have the ability to have another 6" or 9" extender to that to allow for the deeper equipment to reside.

Check with the AHJ for their specific requirements - most are very accommodating and would rather work with you ahead of an install versus the aftermath.

KCDD
Posted By: Mike Andruschak Re: Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/25/08 12:52 PM
Quote
Originally posted by 5Etek-mike:
....ANSI/TIA/EIA-942 [Telecommunications Infrastructure Standard for Data Centers]

Here's the copy and pasted reference:

Hot and Cold Aisles
...Cold aisles are in front of racks and cabinets.
...Hot aisles are behind racks and cabinets.
...A minimum of 1 m (3 ft) of front clearance shall be provided ...1.2 m (4 ft) is preferable
...A minimum of 0.6 m (2 ft) of rear clearance...
:rofl:
Posted By: jeffmoss26 Re: Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/25/08 01:43 PM
Well I guess they better start installing some fiber smile
Posted By: 5Etek-mike Re: Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/25/08 06:30 PM
Just admit it, you were simply thinking ahead for the IT guy! :toothy:
Take some "before" pics while it's still difficult to recognize the area as a call center.
It sounds like a tremendous install!
Posted By: tantivy Re: Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/26/08 11:44 PM
Quote
The first floor is just a single rack, 120 floor positions, 96 LAN ports, in a 100+ square foot room.
Wow.. sounds like fun.. Imagine 120 people and 96 computers in 100 square feet.. :rofl:

I imagine you intended to say "100+ foot square" wink

BTW Mike.. I love reading your blog..
Posted By: Mike Andruschak Re: Equipment Rack Clearance - 01/28/08 09:16 PM
The current call center is at 33.8359,-118.3112 ; the new place is at 33.8394,-118.3109 .

I'm taking pictures, but my card reader died and I've misplaced my camera-usb cable.

The 100 square feet is refering to the terminal room, not the whole floor. As you can see by plugging the above numbers into maps.google.com it's a decent sized building. We have 3/4 of the first floor, all of the second, and none of the third.

The IT guy is (1) an old friend and (2) someone I like owning me a favor.

Blogging is fun. It is also a handy notepad. For instance, I can search for "Douglas" and find the June 11th '07 entry where I note where under the floor I left my three available quads.
© Sundance Business VOIP Telephone Help